The Choice: The Elgato Game Capture HD


Image by yours truly. ME!
Image by yours truly. ME!

If you didn’t know it already, United We Game has now fully entered the gates of video production! Well…mostly fully. I mean, we’re trying our best given that we all have lives outside of UWG. Not that those are of any interest to anyone, so I digress.

A couple months back, The Duck of Indeed regaled us with a fantastic post about her own adventures in recording game play and making videos. Since I finally have a presence on UWG’s YT channel, I figured it was as good a time as any to amuse you with my own stories, which involve a different capture device: the Elgato Game Capture HD. This is a two-parter where here I’ll be answering of the question of “why the Elgato?” and next week I’ll answer the question “what’s it like using the Elgato?”

The choice to get the Elgato, and specifically the Game Capture HD (as opposed to the swanky HD60 model) came down to a couple key features. The device had to be able to capture from both older consoles and an older television set.  By older consoles, I mean the PlayStation 2 and GameCube. And by an older TV set, I mean one that’s seriously pre-HDMI. Like, composite cables only and one lonely S-video hookup.  But the device also had to be able to capture directly from the computer. So it needed to span at least a decade’s worth of A/V technology. No small feat, really.

If you think I’ve lost my mind by going back in time with all this, well…from the get-go, I knew if I was going to venture into video making in earnest that I would start off by recording from older consoles. Though I had run tests of my own capturing gameplay from the Xbox One and PlayStation 4, having access to those systems on a regular basis is simply more complicated because they are hooked up to the house’s primary TV.  The PlayStation 2 and GameCube, meanwhile, reside in a separate area with that old TV. Despite the age of the electronics involved, everything works extremely well. Plus, even though we had made the whole darn setup just for those consoles, they remained mostly ignored. At least now they are getting some use.

But back to the Elgato. I have to admit that my purchasing prowess often veers towards impulse rather than careful. I’ll get in my head that I need [x], and then I’ll go online or go to the store and get the first [x] I see, maybe with a little prior comparison shipping, but nothing extensive. When I decided to get a game capture device though, it was a different story. I put significant effort into choosing the device that was right for me. And my goodness, once I started doing my research, the number of options was overwhelming! Now, given my goal of getting a device that could capture from both and older console and older TV, many options were cut pretty quickly, particularly those that only captured HD video at 1080p or only had HDMI hookups. Nice though many of those devices were, they were not for me.

After developing a number of headaches from too much Googling, I eventually managed to narrow down my options to two: the Elgato Game Capture HD and the Diamond Multimedia USB 2.0 HD 1080.  Honestly, though, there wasn’t much of a competition after that. The Diamond device didn’t have great ratings anywhere I searched, and people complained about its difficult setup. On the other hand, the Elgato came with a stunning amount of praise, with many forums and reviewers saying it was the best thing out there for any type of game capturing. It was all enough to convince me that the Elgato Game Capture HD was just what I needed.

I should point out here that my initial research didn’t include finding out much information about how to actually hook up such a device once it was in my house.  Only after I had placed the order did I realize I probably should have consulted more technical info about it. To that end, I discovered that Elgato’s gaming site was chock full of brilliant online guides and text tutorials all about its Game Capture HD (and HD60). After finding that and subsequently doing more reading, I felt a little more at ease.

I’ve had my Elgato for just over a month now. In that time I’ve complete and bunch of tests and got to making some actually videos. What’s it been like? Is the Elgato as easy to use as every said? Has it accepted the old consoles and TVs without remorse? Come on back next week when I talk all about the practice of using this lovely little device!


  1. Nice! I’m curious to hear your experience with this. It’s what we use to capture at work, and I really love it. I might get one for personal use at some point!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. cary says:

      Thanks! And your workplace sounds awesome! The short version of my own story is that I don’t regret getting the Elgato one bit. More to come next week! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. duckofindeed says:

    I wish I had chosen the Elgato. I didn’t know any capture devices did older consoles, plus, since the LGP advertised its ability to record consoles that only had composite, such as the Wii, I thought that meant it would plug into TVs with only composite. I learned recently that was not the case, and it was mere coincidence I had chosen the HDMI TV to record games. After looking into recording games on my older TV where the majority of consoles reside, I realized that was not possible. Anyway, I might consider getting the Elgato one day so I can record my older consoles. And the LGP will continue to work great with my newer consoles, I suppose.


  3. cary says:

    Reblogged this on Recollections of Play and commented:

    We all have to make tough choices in life.

    Which college do I want to attend?

    Which human being do I want to spend the rest of my life with?

    Which job will provide me with the best experience?

    Which game capture system is right for me?


    Okay, so maybe that’s a case of “one of these things is not like the other.” But when it came to me picking a game capture device, it really was a formidable (if not necessarily life-altering) decision. I recently covered this on United We Game in the post here. I then followed it up with two more posts (listed below) about actually using the device. All around, the Elgato was right for me. If you’re into game capturing, which device is right for you?
    The Experience, Part 1: The Elgato Game Capture HD – Capturing from the PlayStation2 and GameCube
    The Experience, Part 2: The Elgato Game Capture HD – Capturing from PC


Comments are closed.